ACL Tear - KLSMC

Contents

What is ACL Tear

An anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear is a common knee injury involving damage to one of the key ligaments that stabilize the knee joint. The ACL is a strong band of tissue that connects the thigh bone (femur) to the shin bone (tibia) and helps control the back-and-forth movement and rotation of the knee. When the ACL is torn, either partially or completely, the knee’s stability is compromised.

ACL tears are particularly common in sports and athletic activities that involve sudden stops, changes in direction, jumping, or direct impact to the knee. These injuries range in severity from small, partial tears (Grade I or II) to complete ruptures (Grade III) where the ligament is torn into two pieces, leaving the knee unstable.

In Malaysia, data from the National Sports Medicine Centre indicates that ACL tears account for approximately 40% of all serious knee injuries, with particularly high rates in sports such as football (soccer), badminton, and basketball. The condition affects a diverse age range, though the highest incidence is among those aged 15-40 years who participate in sports and physical activities.

Unlike some injuries that heal with rest, a torn ACL has limited capacity for self-repair due to its poor blood supply and formation of synovial tissue around its torn ends. This influences treatment decisions, particularly for active individuals or those with significant knee instability. Understanding this condition, its causes, and treatment options is essential for proper management and optimal recovery.

ACL Tear Symptoms

An ACL tear typically produces distinctive symptoms that develop rapidly after the injury occurs. Recognizing these symptoms early can facilitate prompt medical attention and appropriate management.

Common symptoms that occur at the time of injury include:

Popping sound: A loud “pop” or “snap” often heard or felt at the moment of injury
Immediate pain: Sudden, severe pain in the knee, typically making continued activity impossible
Rapid swelling: Significant swelling that usually develops within 24 hours
Loss of motion: Difficulty bending or straightening the knee fully
Instability: A feeling that the knee will “give way” or buckle when trying to bear weight

After the initial injury, patients typically experience:

Continued instability: The knee feels unstable during pivoting, turning, or twisting movements
Pain with activity: Especially with movements that stress the ACL
Rapid swelling: Significant swelling that usually develops within 24 hours
Limited range of motion: Difficulty fully extending or flexing the knee
Discomfort with walking: Particularly on uneven surfaces or when changing direction

The pattern and severity of symptoms can vary based on whether the tear is partial or complete, and whether other structures in the knee (such as the meniscus or other ligaments) are also injured. The Malaysian Sports Medicine Journal reports that approximately 60% of ACL tears in the Malaysian population are accompanied by damage to other knee structures, particularly the lateral meniscus in the acutely, medial in chronic cases.

It’s important to note that some individuals, particularly those with partial tears, may experience less dramatic symptoms initially and might even be able to continue limited activity. However, continuing to use the knee with an ACL tear, especially in sports or activities involving pivoting or cutting movements, can increase the risk of further damage to the knee’s structures, including cartilage injury and irreparable meniscus tears.

If you experience a combination of these symptoms, particularly following a sports injury or fall, prompt medical evaluation is recommended for proper diagnosis and treatment planning.

What Causes ACL Tear and What are the Risk Factors of ACL Tear

What Causes ACL Tear

ACL tears occur when the ligament is stretched beyond its capacity, resulting in partial or complete disruption of its fibers. This typically happens through specific mechanisms of injury that place excessive stress on the ligament.

Understanding the biomechanics of ACL injuries has advanced significantly, with research clarifying how different movements affect ligament loading and failure.

Several common mechanisms directly cause ACL tears:

Non-contact pivoting: Sudden changes in direction or cutting movements that twist the knee while the foot is planted
Hyperextension: Forceful straightening of the knee beyond its normal range
Deceleration: Rapidly slowing down while running, often combined with a change of direction
Direct impact: A blow to the knee, particularly from the side, that pushes the joint out of alignment
Landing incorrectly: Coming down from a jump with the knee extended or in a valgus (knocked knee) position

Approximately 70% of ACL tears occur through non-contact mechanisms, with the remaining 30% resulting from direct trauma to the knee.

The ligament’s failure typically involves a combination of rotational forces and anterior translation (forward movement) of the tibia relative to the femur, exceeding the ACL’s mechanical strength.

What are the Risk Factors of ACL Tear

Various factors increase the likelihood of experiencing an ACL tear. Some of these factors are modifiable, while others are inherent characteristics that may warrant additional preventive measures.

Anatomical and biomechanical factors: Natural physical characteristics that may predispose individuals to ACL injuries.

Gender: Females have 2-8 times higher risk than males participating in the same activities
Narrow intercondylar notch: The groove at the end of the femur where the ACL passes through
Knee alignment issues: Including knock knees (genu valgum) or hyperextended knees
Leg asymmetries: Differences in strength or coordination between legs
Previous ACL injury: History of ACL tear significantly increases risk for subsequent tears

A study from the National Sports Institute of Malaysia found that female athletes in Malaysia have approximately 4 times higher ACL injury rates than their male counterparts in similar sports, consistent with global trends.

Sports and activity-related factors: Certain activities and movement patterns increase ACL injury risk.

High-risk sports: Activities involving pivoting, cutting, or jumping (football, badminton, basketball)
Playing surface: Artificial turf or surfaces with high friction can increase risk
Footwear: Shoes with high traction may prevent rotation of the foot when the body pivots
Fatigue: Muscle fatigue leads to altered mechanics and decreased knee protection
Competition level: Higher levels of competition often involve more aggressive play and higher forces

Neuromuscular factors: How muscles activate and coordinate can significantly impact injury risk.

Muscle imbalances: Particularly between quadriceps and hamstrings
Poor landing mechanics: Landing from jumps with knees extended or in valgus position
Inadequate core strength: Resulting in poor control of body position during movement
Neuromuscular control deficits: Delays in muscle activation or suboptimal firing patterns

Environmental and situational factors: External elements that may contribute to injury risk.

Weather conditions: Dry conditions may increase shoe-surface friction
Rules and refereeing: In contact sports, rules enforcement can affect injury risk
Protective equipment: Lack of appropriate bracing in previously injured knees

Understanding personal risk factors can help guide targeted prevention strategies. The Malaysian Orthopaedic Association recommends that athletes in high-risk sports, particularly those with multiple risk factors, consider participating in structured injury prevention programs.

ACL Tear Complications

Without proper treatment and rehabilitation, ACL tears can lead to various complications that affect knee function, activity level, and long-term joint health. These potential complications underscore the importance of appropriate management.

Short-term complications may include:

Hemarthrosis: Bleeding within the joint causing pain and swelling
Loss of motion: Developing stiffness and limited range of motion
Muscle atrophy: Rapid weakening of thigh muscles, particularly the quadriceps
Inability to participate: In sports, work, or daily activities due to instability or pain

Long-term complications without proper treatment:

Chronic instability: Persistent feeling of the knee “giving way” during activities
Recurrent injuries: Damage to other structures like menisci due to ongoing instability
Premature osteoarthritis: Accelerated joint degeneration due to altered biomechanics
Activity limitations: Inability to return to previous sports or activity levels

Approximately 60-70% of patients with untreated complete ACL tears develop significant osteoarthritic changes within 15-20 years, compared to 30-40% of those who receive appropriate treatment.

Post-surgical complications: For those who undergo surgical reconstruction, potential complications include:

Graft failure: The new ligament can re-tear, particularly in the first year
Donor site morbidity: Pain or weakness at the site where the graft was harvested
Infection: Though uncommon (1-2%), surgical site infections can occur
Arthrofibrosis: Excessive scar tissue formation limiting knee motion
Hardware issues: Problems with screws or other fixation devices

Psychological impact:

Fear of re-injury: Leading to activity avoidance or altered movement patterns
Sports-related anxiety: Particularly when returning to the activity that caused the injury
Depression: Related to activity limitations or prolonged recovery

The risk and severity of complications correlate with several factors, including injury severity, presence of associated injuries (meniscus, cartilage, or other ligaments), treatment approach, adherence to rehabilitation, and individual patient characteristics like age and activity level.

For young, active individuals, the risk of future knee problems with non-surgical management of complete tears can be substantial. Conversely, older, less active individuals may face fewer complications with non-surgical treatment. The decision about treatment approach should consider these potential complications along with individual goals and lifestyle factors.

How to Prevent ACL Tear

While not all ACL injuries can be prevented, research has shown that specific prevention strategies can significantly reduce the risk, particularly in high-risk populations such as female athletes and those in pivoting sports.

Neuromuscular training programs: Structured exercise regimens designed to improve movement patterns and muscle activation have shown the strongest evidence for prevention.

Jump landing training: Learning to land from jumps with proper knee and hip alignment
Deceleration training: Techniques for slowing down while maintaining control
Cutting and pivoting practice: Developing safer mechanics for direction changes
Proper lifting techniques: Always bend at the knees, not the waist; keep the load close to your body; avoid twisting while lifting
Balance and proprioception exercises: Enhancing awareness of body position
Core and hip strengthening: Improving control of the entire kinetic chain

A prevention program implemented across several sports academies in Malaysia demonstrated a 50-60% reduction in ACL injury rates among participants who completed the structured training at least twice weekly.

Strength and conditioning: Developing appropriate muscle strength and endurance helps protect the knee during athletic movements.

Hamstring strengthening: Balancing quadriceps-to-hamstring strength ratio
Hip abductor and external rotator exercises: Controlling knee position during activity
Eccentric muscle training: Developing control during deceleration movements
Plyometric exercises: Progressive jumping drills to improve landing mechanics

Awareness and technique modification: Education about high-risk movements and situations can help athletes adopt safer behaviors.

Avoiding “high-risk” positions: Such as landing with straight knees or in a knock-kneed position
Proper cutting technique: Learning to pivot with bent knees and proper body positioning
Sport-specific skill development: Enhancing technical proficiency to reduce injury risk
Video feedback: Visual reinforcement of proper versus risky movement patterns

Equipment and environmental considerations: Attention to external factors that may contribute to injury risk.

Appropriate footwear: Matched to the playing surface to optimize traction
Bracing: Prophylactic bracing for high-risk athletes remains controversial but may benefit some
Surface maintenance: Ensuring playing fields are well-maintained without hazards

Fatigue management: Recognizing that injury risk increases with fatigue.

Adequate conditioning: Building endurance to delay onset of fatigue
Proper rest and recovery: Between training sessions and competitions
Substitution strategies: In team sports, rotating players before fatigue becomes significant

The Malaysian Sports Council’s injury prevention guidelines recommend implementing these strategies through a structured warm-up program performed at least 2-3 times weekly, with consistent reinforcement from coaches and medical staff. Programs such as the FIFA 11+ have been successfully adapted for Malaysian athletes across various sports with similar biomechanical demands.

For individuals who have previously injured an ACL, prevention of re-injury becomes even more critical, as the risk of a second tear is significantly higher than the risk of an initial injury.

How to Diagnose ACL Tear

Diagnosing an ACL tear involves a systematic approach combining clinical examination, patient history, and often imaging studies. Accurate diagnosis is essential for appropriate treatment planning.

Clinical history: The diagnostic process typically begins with gathering detailed information about the injury.

Mechanism of injury: How the injury occurred provides important diagnostic clues
Immediate symptoms: Presence of a “pop,” immediate swelling, and inability to continue activity
Prior knee injuries: History of previous knee problems or instability
Activity level: Sports participation and functional requirements

Physical examination: Several specific tests help assess ACL integrity and knee stability.

Lachman test: The gold standard clinical test, assessing anterior translation of the tibia relative to the femur
Anterior drawer test: Evaluating forward movement of the tibia with the knee bent 90 degrees
Pivot shift test: Assessing rotational stability of the knee
Examination for associated injuries: Checking menisci, other ligaments, and cartilage

Imaging studies: Various imaging modalities help confirm the diagnosis and assess associated injuries.

MRI: The preferred imaging method, showing the ACL tear and any associated injuries with approximately 95% accuracy
X-rays: Not diagnostic for ACL tears but can reveal associated fractures or degenerative changes
Ultrasound: May be used in some settings but less accurate than MRI

Differential diagnosis: Several conditions may present with similar symptoms and must be distinguished from ACL tears.

Other ligament injuries: Particularly posterior cruciate or collateral ligament tears
Meniscal tears: May cause pain, swelling, and locking but different patterns of instability
Patellar dislocation: Often occurs with similar mechanisms but different physical findings
Tibial plateau fracture: May present with similar swelling and inability to bear weight

An accurate diagnosis forms the foundation for appropriate treatment selection, with consideration of factors such as injury severity, associated injuries, patient age, activity level, and goals for return to sports or activities.

ACL Tear Treatment

Treatment for ACL tears aims to restore knee stability, manage pain, and allow return to desired activities. The approach varies based on injury severity, patient age, activity level, and associated injuries.

Non-surgical management: For certain patients, conservative treatment may be appropriate.

RICE protocol: Rest, ice, compression, and elevation in the acute phase
Bracing: Stabilizing the knee during healing and daily activities
Physical therapy: Restoring range of motion, strength, and proprioception
Activity modification: Avoiding high-risk movements and pivoting sports
Gradual return to activities: Based on rehabilitation progress and functional testing

Surgical treatment: For tears in active individuals, surgical reconstruction is often recommended.

ACL reconstruction: Replacing the torn ligament with a graft
Graft options:
- Autograft: Using the patient’s own tissue (hamstring, patellar tendon, or quadriceps tendon)
- Allograft: Using donor tissue (less donor site morbidity)
Timing of surgery: Typically delayed until swelling subsides and range of motion improves
Additional procedures: Addressing associated meniscal or cartilage injuries
Rehabilitation: Crucial component beginning immediately after surgery

Rehabilitation protocol: Regardless of treatment approach, rehabilitation is essential for optimal outcomes.

Phase 1 (Early): Focus on swelling control, regaining range of motion, and basic strength
Phase 2 (Intermediate): Progressive strengthening, neuromuscular training, and functional exercises
Phase 3 (Advanced): Sport-specific training, agility, and return-to-play preparation
Return-to-sport testing – Functional assessments before clearance for full activity

International guidelines recommend a minimum of 6-9 months of rehabilitation before return to pivoting sports, with research showing that longer rehabilitation (9-12 months) may reduce re-injury rates by up to 50%.

Treatment decisions should consider both short and long-term goals, with shared decision-making between patients and healthcare providers. Optimal outcomes require not only appropriate initial treatment but also comprehensive

Next Steps

If you’re experiencing symptoms of an ACL tear or have concerns about your knee stability, we encourage you to consult with our specialized healthcare team. Our specialists provide comprehensive evaluation and personalized care plans tailored to your unique needs.

As a leading healthcare provider in Malaysia’s sport industry, and accredited as Asian Football Confederation’s (AFC) first Medical Centre of Excellence, KLSMC attracts patients from around the world seeking high-quality ACL treatment

To schedule an appointment with our specialists, please call +603-2096 1033 or click on our contact us link. Early intervention can significantly improve outcomes and quality of life for individuals with ACL injuries.